Columbia vs. The North Face: Choosing Custom Jackets for Your Team
Columbia vs. The North Face is a familiar outdoor-apparel comparison, but a company jacket order needs a more specific answer. Your team may need a comfortable indoor layer, an insulated jacket for cold commutes, or a shell for rainy days. Those are three different jobs. Start by finishing this sentence: our employees will reach for this jacket when they are doing what? The answer might be commuting on cold mornings, working in a cool office, traveling for meetings, or keeping rain gear close during outdoor events. That sentence does more work than a broad ranking of two brands. It tells you which garment category belongs on the shortlist and which features deserve attention. Once the jacket meets that need, brand preference can help with the final choice. Reversing that order risks buying an impressive gift that is poorly suited to the recipient's routine. Useful company apparel should earn its space in the closet.
Compare the actual jackets
The Columbia Women’s Benton Springs full-zip fleece and The North Face Women’s Everyday Insulated jacket can both become company apparel, but they are not equivalent layers. The Columbia Watertight II rain jacket adds a separate option for employees who need a packable shell. These examples also involve different fits, so keep the comparison honest. A women's fleece and a women's insulated jacket can illustrate two outerwear roles, but they do not establish size equivalence or represent every product either brand makes. A rain shell adds another construction to the decision. If the team needs several fit options, identify the available models and charts for each rather than assuming every pictured style has an identical companion. Build the shortlist around the people who will wear it. A coordinated program can include several appropriate garments while retaining a consistent company identity through logo treatment and a deliberate color palette.
Swipe the table sideways to see all columns.
| Priority | Product to consider | What to understand |
|---|---|---|
| Everyday fleece layering | Columbia Benton Springs | Polyester fleece; plan a separate shell when rain protection is needed |
| Insulated outerwear | The North Face Everyday Insulated, NF0A7V6K | Women’s fit, synthetic insulation, and a water-repellent finish |
| Rain protection and packability | Columbia Watertight II, 153389 | A waterproof, seam-sealed shell; choose warmth layers separately |


For indoor work and flexible layering: start with fleece
If employees spend most of the day indoors and put a jacket on for the commute, a fleece may see more use than a heavier insulated piece. It can be worn over a work shirt without turning every indoor meeting into a jacket-removal exercise. For office use, ask where the current uniform falls short. Is the employee cold at a desk, uncomfortable near a drafty entrance, or looking for a layer during travel? A full-zip fleece can be adjusted or removed easily, but its collar, sleeves, and fit still need to work with the underlying shirt. Try it during ordinary seated movement and reaching. If it will stay on through customer meetings, view the complete outfit rather than judging the jacket alone. The polos versus dress shirts guide can help establish that base uniform first. The outer layer should support the way employees work and present themselves.
Benton Springs is worth considering for that role. Ask wearers to check the fit through the shoulders and hips over their normal uniform. If the jacket must fit under a rain shell, try both layers together; sleeve bulk and collar height matter as much as the letter size. Have the wearer zip the fleece over the normal shirt, then check shoulder movement, body length, and comfort while sitting. If a shell will go over it, add that shell during the fitting. Pay attention to sleeves bunching at the elbow and collars pressing together at the neck. The right letter size in each garment does not automatically mean the combination will feel right. Use the charts to identify candidates, then assess the outfit. Keep a note of the actual layers used so a later reorder repeats the intended combination. A different fleece thickness or cut can change the fit even when the outer jacket stays the same.
Fleece is a warmth layer, so do not infer rain protection from the Columbia name. If the choice is primarily about fleece versus a softshell, our softshell vs. fleece guide compares that decision using OGIO and Port Authority examples. For staff who move repeatedly between indoors and outdoors, a fleece may be one part of the wardrobe rather than the only jacket issued. Give each piece a clear role. The indoor layer can prioritize comfortable everyday wear; a separate shell can address rain exposure when needed. That is often easier to understand than expecting one garment to provide every form of protection. Explore the custom jackets collection with those roles in mind and read the construction of each candidate. A familiar outdoor logo is useful recognition, but the actual model description should determine what the company tells employees to expect from the garment.
For an insulated gift or cold-weather layer: assess The North Face
The women’s Everyday Insulated NF0A7V6K uses a recycled polyester shell, Heatseeker synthetic insulation, and a durable water-repellent finish. Its construction makes it a different proposition from an uninsulated fleece or rain shell. An insulated piece changes the buying conversation. Check the fit with realistic cold-weather layers, the comfort of the collar and cuffs, and the amount of coverage when the wearer sits or reaches. Look at the quilted or paneled areas when planning the logo, since the visible surface may not provide one large uninterrupted space. For a gift, ask whether the recipient already has a preferred heavy coat and whether this jacket fills a useful gap. A lighter indoor layer might see more use for one person, while insulated outerwear could be exactly what another wants. The brand name cannot resolve those individual preferences on its own.
For an employee gift, check whether the recipient will use it as everyday outerwear and whether the offered fit works for them. Brand preference can be a useful tie-breaker once the jacket meets those practical needs. It should not substitute for a size check or a discussion of the conditions in which the jacket will be worn. A simple choice process can preserve the appeal of a company gift while improving fit. Offer a small number of approved styles, explain their intended uses, and let recipients confirm their own size from the correct chart. You can keep the event or presentation a surprise without guessing the garment. If a single style is required, gather enough information to know that its fit range serves the group. The company swag buying guide covers a similar recipient-first approach. The gift feels more thoughtful when the person can picture wearing it regularly, not just when the package carries a recognizable manufacturer name.
The water-repellent finish is not a reason to describe this style as a fully waterproof rain jacket. For sustained rain, look for an explicitly waterproof construction and sealed seams on the actual model. Keep warmth and rain protection as separate requirements on the order brief. A water-repellent finish can be a useful feature, but it should not be turned into an unsupported promise about sustained exposure. If staff need a dedicated rain garment, identify that requirement before choosing the insulated piece as the only outer layer. Our waterproof versus water-resistant guide explains the difference between surface repellency and the construction of a rain jacket. That distinction also helps recipients use the wardrobe sensibly. They should know which piece was selected for warmth and which was selected to address the rain conditions described in the program.
For rain: compare shells with shells
The Watertight II model 153389 is a more relevant starting point when the requirement is a waterproof shell that packs into its pocket. Columbia specifies Omni-Tech construction and full seam sealing for this model. A packable shell is especially worth considering when the jacket will spend part of its time in a bag or vehicle. Try the packing feature on a sample and see whether it fits the intended storage space. For an outdoor event kit, pair it with the items staff actually carry rather than evaluating the jacket in isolation. A custom backpack or another suitable bag may complete that setup, but the bundle should remain practical and easy to carry. The useful question is whether the shell will be available when needed. A garment with excellent listed features provides little value if its size or carrying routine causes people to leave it behind.
A shell also lets employees choose a separate warmth layer. That flexibility can suit teams working across changing seasons, but it means the order brief should specify the layer worn underneath. Trying a shell over only a T-shirt may not reveal whether it fits comfortably over the winter uniform. Write down the thickest normal layer employees will wear under the shell. A tee for a summer event and a sweatshirt for a cold commute create different fitting conditions. Test the realistic combination with the shell zipped, then check shoulder movement, sleeve length, and the hem while seated. Avoid adding an arbitrary extra size for layers when the garment may already include room. Equally, do not approve a close fit over a thin shirt if the actual uniform is bulkier. The hoodie fabric-weight guide can help distinguish the inner layers you are comparing before you settle the outer size.
For another shell comparison, see Eddie Bauer vs. Columbia company jackets. That guide looks at WeatherEdge and Watertight II features within the same general category. When comparing shells across brands, keep the questions consistent: What construction is stated? How are seams treated? What adjustments are provided? How does it fit over the uniform? Where can the company logo go? Then compare the complete decorated price under the same assumptions. This is more useful than scoring one brand's fleece against another brand's rain jacket and calling the result a general winner. If the team has several roles, you may end up with a shell for some employees and a fleece or insulated piece for others. That can be a clear, intentional program when the reason for each option is explained.
Make room for two brands on one jacket
Your logo will share space with the manufacturer’s branding. On the North Face jacket shown here, the existing left-chest mark means the usual default position for a company logo is already occupied. A right-chest placement may be a candidate, but the exact panel and decoration area need review before production. Co-branding deserves a real design review. Your company mark and the manufacturer's mark will appear together, so decide how they should balance. A large company logo may crowd a small chest panel, while an overly subtle mark can disappear beside the existing branding. Print the proposed design on paper at actual size and hold it against the sample in an approved position. View it from normal conversation distance. Ask whether the name is readable and whether the layout feels balanced. The answer may be a simpler logo version, a different scale, or another offered position. Use the garment's actual construction to guide that decision.
The Benton Springs and Watertight II catalog photos show company decoration on the wearer’s right chest, opposite Columbia’s mark. Use those images as examples, not permission to place any design at any size. Zippers, quilt lines, pockets, and seams can change the usable space. For mixed models, create a separate proof for each one. Label the wearer's side explicitly and record the finished width and height of the artwork. A mirrored image or a casually described left side can cause confusion. Also inspect the smallest garment size in the order when deciding whether one logo size works across the range. A detailed crest that fits one sample comfortably may need simplifying elsewhere. If the company also issues embroidered polos, keep their approvals separate. Consistency comes from a recognizable identity, not from forcing identical physical dimensions onto every jacket and shirt in the wardrobe.
For waterproof shells, ask how the selected decoration method affects the weather barrier. Embroidery introduces needle holes; the finished jacket’s protection depends on the placement and any compatible sealing treatment. Clarify this when rain performance is central to the purchase. Bring the intended use into the decoration discussion. Tell the production team if rain protection is central to the purchase and ask how the proposed method interacts with the shell. Request a model-specific recommendation about the location and any compatible treatment, and keep the approved expectation with the order. A factory specification describes the original garment; the finished customized configuration needs its own consideration. This conversation is best held before collecting final sizes or approving artwork. If the desired decoration conflicts with a critical requirement, there is still time to choose a different application or garment that better serves the brief.
Build a team order that works across roles
- Separate employees by actual need: indoor layer, insulated outerwear, or rain shell.
- Check the offered fit and exact size chart for each selected product.
- Choose a shared color direction and thread palette across the group.
- Approve a proof for every jacket style rather than reusing one placement automatically.
- Compare complete decorated pricing and confirm size availability before collecting final approvals.
Common questions
Is The North Face always warmer than Columbia?
No. Compare specific insulation and jacket construction, not brand names. A comparison between an insulated jacket and a fleece does not establish a winner across either brand’s range. A useful comparison names the actual layers: this fleece for indoor warmth, this insulated jacket for the defined outerwear role, and this shell for the stated rain requirement. It does not turn those examples into a verdict on every Columbia or North Face product. If warmth is the deciding factor, review the insulation and construction of the specific finalists, then try them with the intended outfit. Personal comfort, movement, and exposure all affect the experience. Treat a sample fitting as a way to choose a practical garment, not as a laboratory test. Keep the claims in the order description aligned with what the available specifications actually support.
Which brand is better for company gifts?
The better gift is the one recipients can use and comfortably wear. Consider their climate, style preference, fit, and the finished appearance of both logos. Value is broader than the first price shown on a listing. Compare the final decorated total using the same quantity, size distribution, artwork, locations, and delivery requirement. Include agreed setup and shipping costs where applicable. Then consider how often the recipients are likely to wear the item and whether the fit choices cover the group well. A more expensive brand may be worth choosing when recipients strongly prefer the appropriate model, but the name should not excuse a poor fit or an unsuitable construction. For a limited budget, one well-chosen garment can make a stronger gift than several loosely related items that people are unlikely to use.
Can the whole team wear different styles and still look coordinated?
Yes. Keep the company logo treatment consistent and select compatible colors. Separate fits or weather requirements can justify different garments without losing a unified look. Keep a shared visual thread through a mixed order: the same core symbol, an approved thread palette, and colors that coordinate in person. Inspect samples together if the group will be photographed as a uniformed team. Two products called navy can look different because of shade, texture, and sheen, so decide how close the match needs to be. Save each product code, size chart, artwork proof, and color choice for future additions. This makes a flexible program manageable. New employees can select the appropriate approved style without forcing the organizer to reconstruct the original decisions from a group photograph or an old invoice description.
Browse our custom jackets collection to compare the available products and build your team’s shortlist. Finish the handoff with care information and a clear record of what was ordered. Recipients should follow the actual garment label together with any decoration guidance, especially when the program includes fleece, insulated pieces, and rain shells. The embroidered apparel care guide offers a useful starting point for that discussion. After people have worn the jackets, ask one practical question: what would make the next order more useful? Feedback about collar comfort, layering, storage, or preferred fit is far more valuable than a general vote for a brand. It gives the next purchase a concrete basis for improvement.
Specification references: The North Face NF0A7V6K and Columbia Watertight II 1533891. Recommendations are based on listed construction and intended use, not comparative field testing.
Keep Reading
Crewneck vs. Hoodie: Which Works Better for You...
Choose between a crewneck sweatshirt and a hoodie using a practical comparison of layering, coverage, artwork placement, and what your group will wear.
Richardson 112 vs. 115: Which Is Better for You...
Compare the Richardson 112 and 115 by crown height, fit, and logo placement. Use our practical checklist to choose custom hats your team will want to wear.
Cotton vs. Polyester Hoodies: Which Should You ...
Compare cotton, polyester, and common hoodie blends by comfort, moisture, care, and decoration—then use actual product examples to narrow your choice.
Hoodie GSM Explained: How to Choose the Right F...
Learn what hoodie GSM measures, compare actual fabric weights, and choose a comfortable weight for offices, school groups, gifts, and cool-weather layering.
- Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
- Opens in a new window.